4 min. reading

Gen Z More Open to AI Influencers But Cares Less About Authenticity

Something big is happening in influencer marketing. While brands experiment with AI-generated personalities, most people still don't trust them. The twist? Authenticity might not matter as much as everyone thinks.

Katarína Šimčíková Katarína Šimčíková
Freelance I Digital Marketing Specialist, Ecommerce Bridge EU
This article was translated for you by artificial intelligence
Gen Z More Open to AI Influencers But Cares Less About Authenticity
Source: Canva Pro License

Trust Issues Are Real

Sprout Social asked 2,000 people what they think about AI influencers. The results are pretty telling. 37% would feel distrustful of brands using artificial personalities. Another 27% couldn’t even spot the difference between AI and human influencers. Only 37% showed any interest in brands partnering with AI creators.

Gen Z leads acceptance at 46%, but that’s still less than half. Even digital natives aren’t rushing to embrace artificial influencers. Brands jumping into AI partnerships might be moving faster than their audiences want.

Chart displaying consumer reactions to AI influencers: 37% more interested, 37% distrustful, 27% indifferent and unable to distinguish AI from human.

Source: sproutsocial.com

The Authenticity Problem That Isn’t

Here’s where things get weird. The same generation most open to AI influencers cares least about authenticity. Only 35% of Gen Z values how “real” an influencer is. Compare that to about half of older generations who still think authenticity matters.

“Authenticity is overrated,” says Melo Meacher-Jones from Accenture Song. “We follow influencers not because we believe they’re authentic, but because they entertain or interest us.” – according to the report.

Think about it. Brands worry AI influencers lack authenticity. But younger consumers – the ones actually engaging with this content – don’t prioritize authenticity anyway.

They Get the Business Side

Younger audiences grew up with sponsored posts everywhere. They understand influencer marketing is a business transaction, not friendship. They don’t want authenticity. They want to see how products work and fit into real life.

Gen Z and Millennials buy stuff based on influencer recommendations way more than older people do. They’re not looking for genuine connections. They want entertaining product demos that actually help them decide what to buy.

Moving Beyond Instagram

The future of influencer marketing goes way past social media posts. 80% of consumers would be more willing to buy from brands that partner with influencers on other projects. We’re talking in-person events, brand trips, and multichannel ad campaigns.

Influencers are basically becoming the new actors. As celebrity culture shifts, they’re sliding into spokesperson roles that used to belong to traditional stars.

Bar chart showing 80% of consumers willing to buy from brands partnering with influencers beyond social media: 22% strongly agree, 58% somewhat agree, 17% somewhat disagree, 3% strongly disagree.

Source: sproutsocial.com

AI and Humans Will Coexist

Despite consumer hesitation, AI influencers aren’t disappearing. Industry experts think they’ll work alongside human creators rather than replace them completely. Some see potential for better brand partnerships since AI personalities can be fully controlled and aligned with brand values.

“I would definitely be interested in consuming a brand’s ad knowing they used AI or virtual influencers,” notes Georgina Whalen from The Influence Atelier in the report. “It allows me to focus solely on the brand and their generated creative versus the brand and an external party.”

What Brands Should Actually Do

The research suggests caution. Technology might enable AI influencers, but consumer acceptance isn’t there yet. Instead of rushing into artificial personalities, smart brands focus on what actually drives engagement:

  • entertainment value
  • useful product demonstrations
  • experiences across multiple channels

The data also challenges everything we thought we knew about authenticity. Brands obsessing over “authentic” partnerships might be solving the wrong problem. Especially for younger audiences who already understand and accept the commercial nature of influencer content.

Three Trends Shaping the Future

  1. Technology integration will happen slowly. AI influencers will complement human creators, not replace them entirely.
  2. Authenticity concerns will fade as audiences get comfortable with obviously artificial content – as long as it’s entertaining and useful.
  3. Channel expansion beyond social media becomes standard. Influencers take on broader spokesperson roles across multiple touchpoints.

The Bottom Line

Influencer marketing is still pretty new. Success comes from understanding what audiences actually want: entertainment and useful product information. Not some outdated idea of authentic relationships.

Brands that get this shift and adapt will win the next phase of influencer marketing. Whether that involves human creators, AI personalities, or some hybrid approach that blends both.

Share article
Katarína Šimčíková
Freelance I Digital Marketing Specialist, Ecommerce Bridge EU

Freelance Digital Marketing Specialist at Ecommerce Bridge with nearly a decade of experience in digital marketing, where I’ve specialised in managing international teams and building strategic partnerships. As former International Team Lead at Groupon, I managed teams across various European countries, handled KPI achievement, and worked daily with agencies in English. These days, I focus on content strategy, link building, and coordinating with international agencies in e-commerce expansion. What truly fulfils me is working with people and seeing everyone happy and satisfied with the results. I’m passionate about researching and writing about the latest trends in e-commerce and digital marketing, bringing fresh insights and industry news to our readers. I hold a Master’s degree in Mass Media Studies and completed international courses in London and Bristol.

Similar articles
Influencers Want Fair Pay and Creative Control, Not Brand Fame
4 min. reading

Influencers Want Fair Pay and Creative Control, Not Brand Fame

Brands chasing influencer partnerships are missing the point completely. New research shows influencers care way more about shared values and clear payment than working with popular brands. And they want creative input that most companies won’t give them.

Katarína Šimčíková Katarína Šimčíková
Freelance I Digital Marketing Specialist, Ecommerce Bridge EU
User-Generated Content in Influencer Campaigns: Why It’s a Game-Changer for E-commerce Brands
4 min. reading

User-Generated Content in Influencer Campaigns: Why It’s a Game-Changer for E-commerce Brands

User-Generated Content (UGC) and influencer marketing are two of the most powerful tools in digital marketing today—but are they the same thing? Not exactly. As the founder of an agency that works with over 1600 content creators and has run campaigns for brands like Oriflame, EasyFishOil, Ozone.bg, Pepco, Doctor Switz, TEDi, Stylewish, and many more, […]

Radostina Hristova  Radostina Hristova 
Influencer & Digital Marketing Professional, Radostna.com, Influencermedia.bg
Why is Influencer Marketing Important?
3 min. reading

Why is Influencer Marketing Important?

In order to connect with the target audience and stand out from the crowd, brands are constantly looking for new tricks. Influencer marketing is a dynamic strategy that is transforming how companies communicate with their customers.